609-575-8626 Text Jeff Email Jeff Serving Naples & Collier County
Ask Jeff
Jeff Silberman seated, wearing a white shirt, smiling
Home or a move · Naples, FL

Home Care vs. Moving in Naples

A Naples-focused comparison of staying at home with help versus moving to senior living, using official National Institute on Aging, Medicare, and CareScout figures. Jeff Silberman can go over both paths with the family one-on-one.

The official starting point

Staying at home, or moving, is a family decision

The National Institute on Aging says most people prefer to stay in their own home for as long as possible, and that there may come a time when it is no longer safe or comfortable to live alone. One person may want to move because the house is too much to manage. For another, the need for regular, hands-on care motivates a change. Learn the housing options, and talk with the family about the pros and cons of each option before making a decision.

If a move becomes necessary, NIA points families to transition help from health care professionals, a local senior center, or the Area Agency on Aging. In this area, that includes the Area Agency on Aging for Southwest Florida and the Florida Elder Helpline.

Sources: National Institute on Aging, aging in place; National Institute on Aging, what is long-term care.

Comparing costs

Compare hours at home with a written community rate

The CareScout Cost of Care Survey 2025, collected from July through November 2025, lists a Florida median of $32 an hour for a non-medical caregiver, or $6,101 a month at the survey 44-hours-a-week basis ($73,216 a year). The same survey lists a Florida median of $5,610 a month, or $67,320 a year, for an assisted living community.

Those are different products. The in-home figure is an hourly rate at a stated weekly-hours assumption, not a 24-hour quote. Overnight or around-the-clock help will change the total. The assisted living figure is a monthly community fee that may or may not include the level of care a person actually needs. Naples prices can differ from the statewide median. If a provider has not published a current rate, call for pricing. The Naples senior living cost guide has the full official table and program rules.

Medicare can cover certain part-time or intermittent home health services if a person is eligible and homebound, but Medicare.gov says it does not pay for 24-hour-a-day care at home or for custodial care alone. Medicare also does not pay the monthly assisted living fee.

Sources: CareScout Cost of Care Survey 2025, document 282102 (dated 03/02/26); Medicare.gov, home health services.

Next steps in Naples

Guides, towns, and a call to Jeff

Read the home care, respite, assisted living, and moving and downsizing guides. If a house may need to be sold as part of a move, Jeff can help as a licensed real estate agent; see Moving & Downsizing.

Senior placement pages for each town — including North Naples, the City of Naples and Old Naples, and East Naples — list nearby hospitals, transit, and licensed facility counts from official records.

FAQ

Home care or a move: questions families ask

Is it better to stay at home in Naples or move to assisted living?

The National Institute on Aging says most people prefer to stay in their own home for as long as possible, and that there may come a time when it is no longer safe or comfortable to live alone. There is no single official answer for every family. Compare the help needed, whether that help is available at home, the cost of in-home care at the hours actually required, and what a licensed community would include in a written rate.

How do home-care and assisted-living costs compare?

The CareScout Cost of Care Survey 2025 lists a Florida median of $32 an hour for a non-medical caregiver, or $6,101 a month at 44 hours a week, and a Florida median of $5,610 a month for an assisted living community. Those are different products: one is an hourly in-home rate at a stated weekly hours assumption, and the other is a monthly community fee. More hours at home, overnight care, or 24-hour care will change the home-care total. Get a written in-home estimate and a written community rate for the same person.

Does Medicare pay for full-time home care in Naples?

No. Medicare can cover certain part-time or intermittent home health services if a person is eligible and homebound, but Medicare.gov says it does not pay for 24-hour-a-day care at home or for custodial care alone. Medicare also does not pay the monthly assisted living fee. Short-term skilled nursing facility care after a qualifying inpatient hospital stay is a different benefit, explained on the skilled nursing guide.

Who can help a Naples family decide?

Jeff Silberman can go over options with the family one-on-one, including staying at home with help or looking at senior placement in Naples and nearby. Official starting points include the Florida Elder Helpline, the Area Agency on Aging for Southwest Florida, and FloridaHealthFinder. If a house may need to be sold as part of a move, Jeff can also help as a licensed real estate agent.

One call handles it all

Placement, the move, the house, and everything in between.

Jeff Silberman has 15 years of experience in geriatric and senior care in Naples, and he is a licensed real estate agent. Jeff is paid by the communities, so families don’t have to worry about it. For real estate, Jeff will figure everything out with you.

A smiling older couple sitting together on a couch
1

Senior living placement

Finding communities and help with every step of the search.

Two older women packing belongings into boxes
2

Moving a loved one in

Help moving a loved one into the community once a place is chosen.

A helper cooking with an older man at home
3

Help for the person at home

Support for the spouse or family member who is not moving.

A house with palm trees and flowers in front of it
4

The house, if it is part of the plan

Selling the old home or finding a new one. Jeff is a licensed real estate agent.

Papers and a magnifying glass on a desk
5

Trusted resources for the move

Moving, downsizing, estate sales, estate planning, and other move help.

Ask Jeff

A local person to call.

Jeff Silberman lives in Naples. Call or email with a question.